Showing posts with label Iraq. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iraq. Show all posts

Monday, February 8, 2010

Israel, Palestine, Blair and irony

How are things going for Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank? Not well.

The Guardian reports that "the so-called peace process cannot be revived because Israel refuses to freeze settlement expansion on the West Bank. Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu recently agreed to a temporary freeze of 10 months, but this does not apply to the 3,000 pre-approved housing units to be built on the West Bank or to any part of Greater Jerusalem. It's like two men negotiating the division of a pizza while one continues to gobble it up."

Egypt is helping Israel choke Gaza and Hamas, and Israel refuses to talk to Hamas. Gaza residents see no hope of climbing out of their poverty.

One of the bitter ironies of the U.S.-U.K. invasion of Iraq is that it has meant less attention paid to the plight of Palestinians. At least, it's an irony if you are former British prime minister Tony Blair.

"One of Blair's arguments used to justify the Iraq war was that it would help bring justice to the long-suffering Palestinians. In his House of Commons speech on 18 March 2003, he promised that action against Iraq would form part of a broader engagement with the problems of the Middle East. He even declared that resolving the Israeli-Palestinian dispute was as important to Middle East peace as removing Saddam Hussein from power.

"Yet by focusing international attention on Iraq, the war further marginalised the Palestinian question."


But the Iraq invasion was all about freedom and liberating people from an oppressive government, right? Or was it all about removing weapons of masss destruction? Whatever.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

After 9-11, Washington squandered good will

The eighth anniversary of the Sept. 11 atrocities has passed, with much ink and TV time spent on the matter.
What hasn't been discussed enough, and needs to be repeated to "patriots" in the U.S. until it sinks into their consciousness, is how the intense outpouring of good will and sympathy that followed the attack on the World Trade Center was squandered by the Bush White House.
Practically the whole world - the non-Muslim world, at least - was as unified as one could reasonably expect it to be in its reaction to the attacks.
Team Bush could have built on that. Instead it insisted on not just retaliating against al-Qaida and the country that harboured its leadership, but engaging in a full-blown occupation that continues to this day.
As if that wasn't bad enough, it plunged headlong into making a phony case for invading a country that had nothing to do with the 9-11 attacks. Then it went ahead and invaded and occupied that country as well.
I've come across many assertions since the 2003 Iraq incursion that it wasn't illegal.
Rather than spending a whole lot of time and effort writing a case for how stupid those assertions are, I'll briefly point to a few things the Bush apologists ought to think about.
In the weeks preceding the invasion, other countries pointed out at the United Nations that the U.S./British case for invading Iraq lacked legal foundation and said weapons inspection should be allowed to continue. Regardless, the invasion was launched in defiance of the UN.
In 2004, the UN's highest-ranking official bluntly told the BBC that the invasion violated the UN charter.
A Counterpunch essay details ways in which the Iraq War may reasonably be considered "completely illegal, according to the existing body of international law regarding military interventions."
Finally, Gwynne Dyer skewered the "moral case for invading Iraq" a year after the invasion. It's possibly Dyer's best column ever.

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

On my night table: Web of Deceit

1921: Britain appoints Prince Faisal of Saudi Arabia king of the new country of Iraq; rigged elections are held to give him a patina of legitimacy.
1939: Faisal's successor, his son Ghazi, dies in suspicious circumstances and is succeeded by a very pro-British regency.
1945: A U.S. State Department memo describes Iraqi oil reserves as "a stupendous source of strategic power and one of the great material prizes in world history."
1963: Nationalist Iraqi President Qasim is overthrown in a coup backed heavily by the U.S. and U.K.; a TV camera records his execution.
1968: A CIA-sparked coup consolidates power for the Baath party which includes Saddam Hussein.
1975: U.S., Iranian and Israeli material support for a Kurdish rebellion is withdrawn suddenly; thousands of Kurds are killed by Iraqi troops, and Kurdish villages are destroyed.
1980-1988: The U.S. supports Iraq in its war with Iran, and also supports Iran through proxy Israel. Former U.S. secretary of state (and, ironically, Nobel Peace Prize winner) Kissinger wants both sides to "kill each other."
1988: Saddam kills thousands of Kurds with chemical weapons supplied to Iraq with U.S. approval.
1991: The U.S. encourages Iraqis to overthrow their government, but then refuses to help them as the ensuing uprising is brutally squashed; countless Kurds and Shiites are slaughtered as nearby U.S. troops refuse any support to them.
... And those are just "highlights" from the first 71 years following the creation of Iraq as a country.
Many items are omitted for brevity's sake, and the list stops before the U.S. and U.K. insisted on prolonging a UN embargo for many years at a cost of perhaps 500,000 -- and maybe more -- Iraqi lives.
Then there's the bullshit propagated by the U.S. and British governments to justify military actions that killed many more Iraqis and displaced millions.
Given the history of Western treachery in Iraq (and Iran, and indeed the entire Middle East), is it any wonder Iraqis might have had trouble believing the Dubya administration had their best interests at heart?
"It is the cumulative impact of each cynical episode of foreign intervention in Iraq, year after tawdry year, that I find so shocking," Barry Lando writes in his book's Introduction.
Cynical and tawdry are appropriate words, though perhaps a bit too kind.

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Let freedom ring

Remember how the Bush administration liked to call its most notorious military action Operation Iraqi Freedom? Well, here's freedom for ya: 100 Iraqis face imminent execution for being gay.
Meanwhile, in Afghanistan, it's now perfectly OK for a man to rape his wife or marry a child.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Sun Media's Mansur frames the discussion

Salim Mansur, who called Obama "Marxian" and predicted a McCain victory, squats and drops another big turd of a neo-con talking point:
"But long after the critics of Bush have bitten dust and been forgotten, people will be talking about him, as they do about Truman, reflecting upon the consequences of his decision that brought freedom for 50 million people in the Arab-Muslim world. How these people build positively upon their freedom, or squander it, will be a commentary upon them and not Bush."
See what he did there? By his logic, the Shrub administration did a good thing by invading and occupying a country on false pretenses; now, if the Iraqis can't make the very most of the enormous death toll and the displacement of millions from their homes and the anger of a people whose home turf was taken over by soldiers who couldn't even bother to pronounce the country's name correctly ... (deep breath and heavy sigh) ... well, that reflects poorly on them, not anyone in this part of the world.
Nice framing there.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

The right reasons for opposing a war

As Barack Obama's inauguration nears, it's a good time to reflect on one of his finest moments.
He made a speech at a rally in Chicago, in the fall of 2002, eloquently proclaiming his opposition to the Bush administration's war plans.
He expressed morally correct reasons for his opposition to the invasion of Iraq, reasons that weren't centred around the shallow calculation of whether U.S. forces could "win" and get out quickly.
"What I am opposed to," he said, "is the cynical attempt by Richard Perle and Paul Wolfowitz and other armchair, weekend warriors in this administration to shove their own ideological agendas down our throats, irrespective of the costs in lives lost and in hardships borne. ...
"That's what I'm opposed to. A dumb war. A rash war. A war based not on reason but on passion, not on principle but on politics.
"
The speech was not perfect. Obama seemed to give little thought to the war's inevitably huge Iraqi death toll, as if Iraqi lives weren't so important to him. Nor did the speech give much indication that he cared about the implications of the U.S. signaling (once again) that invading countries is OK.
But still, Obama opposed the Iraq invasion at a time when many supposedly "good" people in America were eager to see it happen.
Contrast that with those today who have grown opposed to the Iraq occupation or how the Bush administration managed it. Those people are, as Scott Ritter has said, not anti-war but anti-losing. They're now opposed to the war only because it is costing their country too much. Which is a shallow, morally bankrupt position.
While we're at it, contrast Obama's position then, back in 2002, with Hillary Clinton's support for war.
And Canadians may contrast it with the support today's leader of the Liberal Party of Canada and today's Prime Minister voiced in 2002-03 for an invasion that the United States had no moral authority to conduct.
When Obama assumes office Tuesday, he'll be walking on moral high ground to which Michael Ignatieff, Stephen Harper and other Iraq war supporters can lay no claim.

Monday, July 28, 2008

About that Surge ...

The Surge - that extra 30,000 U.S. troops sent to Iraq last year - worked, and Barack Obama obviously was wrong to have opposed it. Right?
Not so fast.
"Obama won’t admit a mistake, because he is a smart guy – capable of understanding that foreign policy analysis can't be popped out of a cereal box like a plastic decoder ring. He gets that the drop in violence resulted from a convergence of events 'on the ground' that had as much to do with paying our former enemies to stop fighting us, the so-called 'Anbar Awakening' that started before The Surge and the sectarian cleansing, as it did with the insertion of 30,000 more US troops into Iraq. Plus, Maliki found a way to ensure that his own militia – the Iraqi Army, plus an assist from the the Iranian-backed Badr Brigade –won the war of competing Shia factions in Basra and elsewhere, and Sadr's milita in Baghdad is still lying low in a likely shrewd political calculation ..."
Then there's a host of other things to consider. Like, for instance, whether Afghanistan (where Al Qaida was, after all) shouldn't have been (and still be) a greater priority. And whether sending still more troops to bolster the occupation of Iraq might further inflame anti-American sentiment in the Islamic world. And whether the occupiers can claim success when millions of Iraqis remain displaced from their homes, countless Iraqi families are still in grief from losing parents and children to violence, and the country is divided in three.
Of course, the Republicans demanding Obama cop to his "mistake" on The Surge never touch on those inconvenient truths.
Whether The Surge truly has been a success seems debatable, to say the least.