Showing posts with label Winfrey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Winfrey. Show all posts

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Newsweek calls Oprah on her baloney. Yay!

There's no denying Oprah Winfrey has a nice personality and has done good things in her reign as Queen of Talkshowdom. Heck, she gave away cars.
But skeptical corners of the blogosphere have been pointing out for, well, about as long as there's been a blogosphere, that her show has done harm by propagating quackery, supernatural beliefs and pseudoscience.
I was pleased to see part of the mainstream media finally call her on it with a cover story titled "Live Your Best Life Ever!"
Newsweek suggests Miss Oprah has done her viewers a disservice by letting guests spread not just lousy science but dangerous nonsense.
The two best-known examples involve former Playboy model Jenny McCarthy and former sitcom star Suzanne Somers.
McCarthy has been on Oprah repeatedly telling moms to not have their children vaccinated; she's convinced that a vaccine caused her son's autism because soon after getting his shot she could see the "soul gone from his eyes."
Non-doctor Somers has touted "bio-identical" hormones as if she's an expert; apparently she takes dozens of pills daily and injects estrogen into her vagina. Seriously.
Miss Oprah doesn't just let her kooky guests speak their piece, she voices support for their yammerings. And she marginilizes true medical experts by placing them in the audience to speak briefly while the likes of Somers and McCarthy are seated on stage and get far more time to speak.
Overall, Newsweek has done a good job with its story, which has sparked quite a lot of discussion in the blogosphere.
As one science blogger remarked, "it's about time one of the big media players pointed out that [Winfrey] is promoting dangerous fake therapies … all with a happy smile, of course, and a message of positive self-esteem for women. It's still credulous glop, though."