Showing posts with label oil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oil. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

So crazy it might work?

In the 1950s, some genius working for a U.S. oil company had an idea for extracting oil from the tarsands in northern Alberta: Why not put nuclear bombs below ground, where those oil-soaked sands are, and detonate them? The heat would cause the oil to boil out and puddle up into nice pockets that could be pumped out.

Sounds crazy, right? But the idea was taken seriously, for a while at least. And it doesn't seem much crazier than pressurizing carbon dioxide so that it liquifies, and then putting it underground as a way of reducing the amount of CO2 released into the atmosphere. Which is basically what "carbon capture and storage" (CCS) is.

And Canadian governments (federal and provincial) have committed to spending billions of dollars on this latest mad science.

I thought of this as I read Frances Russell's column in the Winnipeg Free Press today. She quotes William Marsden (in whose book you can read more about that nuclear-bomb idea) as opining that CCS is "too expensive, is untested and it won't store enough carbon." Not to mention that it's dangerous.

I'm sure many experts would agree. Maybe not the industry-supplied "experts" Environment Minister Prentice is fond of consulting, but probably the environmentally minded experts he deems unworthy of his time. Perhaps the minister should pay attention to those people.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Diamond on oil

Here's Jared Diamond being interviewed on TV in 2008, when crude prices were around $120 a barrel.