Showing posts with label Gerrard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gerrard. Show all posts

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Liberals do the right thing, NDP balks

From The Canadian Press: "WINNIPEG — The fur is set to fly in Manitoba over whether landlords should be forced to accept tenants with pets.

"Animal owners are lining up behind an opposition bill that, if passed into law, would outlaw no-pet rules at rental properties across the province.

"'There is much greater support for this than I ever anticipated,' said Liberal Leader Jon Gerrard. 'There's a lot of passion when I talk about it with individual people who have to give up their pets when they move into apartments.'

"Since the end of January, more than 2,500 people have signed up on a Facebook page to support Gerrard's bill, which was tabled at the end of the legislature's fall sitting. Groups such as the Winnipeg Humane Society have joined the battle and are calling on the NDP government to pass the bill."


For me, this is great news. I live with a cat, and I can tell you that Ontario has had a ban on "no pets" policies for many years, and it hasn't pushed landlords out of business. I lived in Ontario for several years, and I can tell you the system isn't collapsing due to a ban on no-pets policies.

I would expect the governing NDP, a nominally social democratic party, to be on the side of the property-less over the property owners in a case like this. Here's a chance for social democrats to show their superior capacity for compassion, right?

Sadly, no.

"'It is hoped that the damage deposit provision ... will encourage more landlords to welcome tenants with pets,' Rachel Morgan, press secretary to Family Services Minister Gord Mackintosh, wrote in an email."

Oh, yes. That idea. Pet damage deposits. An idea lifted from British Columbia's right-wing government, without any evidence that it has succeeded in producing more pet-friendly accommodations for renters.

Brilliant play, that.

"Gerrard is hopeful, however, that the government may change its mind, especially in the face of public pressure."

Good luck with that. The current premier is the guy who pushed the damage-deposit policy through (when he was finance minister) despite the extra burden it will mean to pet owners, and despite the utter lack of evidence that it's an effective policy in any way. He considered the landlords' viewpoints, paid no attention to any arguments against the policy, and gave the landlords a gift like any good friend of the powerful would.

It's not too late for the NDP to show that it cares, but I won't hold my breath waiting for that to happen.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Dear Mr. Gerrard:

(E-mail sent this morning to the Manitoba Liberal Leader.)

I wish to bring your attention to amendments the Doer government is considering for the Residential Tenancies Act, to allow landlords to charge a "pet deposit."

My concern is that landlords will be allowed to impose another charge (albeit a deposit) on tenants but still be allowed to impose inflexible "no pets" policies -- just as Globe General Agencies and other companies do for all of their rental properties. If that's the case, an extra cost would be imposed on pet owners while giving them no more rights than they have under the status quo.

The result could be that pet owners will have just as few choices as presently among rental units but an additional cost. Rather than an advance in tenants' rights, this would be a setback.

Ontario has had a ban on landlord "no pets" policies for several years, and I can tell you as a former Ontario resident of many years that it has been successful. Renters live happily and healthily in their suites, and landlords continue to reap profits. There is no reason why inflexible "no pets" policies can't be banned here too, contrary to whatever alarmist objections landlords may raise.

Now is the time for the Manitoba government to act out of compassion for people who have companion animals but not enough money to purchase a house, so that people will no longer be forced to lie to landlords about having a cat or dog, and so that no octogenarian should be forced to forsake the quiet and peaceful cat that has been her companion for many years.

All that is required is a simple legislative amendment, which I hope you and your party would support.

Sincerely ...