From The Canadian Press: "WINNIPEG — The fur is set to fly in Manitoba over whether landlords should be forced to accept tenants with pets.
"Animal owners are lining up behind an opposition bill that, if passed into law, would outlaw no-pet rules at rental properties across the province.
"'There is much greater support for this than I ever anticipated,' said Liberal Leader Jon Gerrard. 'There's a lot of passion when I talk about it with individual people who have to give up their pets when they move into apartments.'
"Since the end of January, more than 2,500 people have signed up on a Facebook page to support Gerrard's bill, which was tabled at the end of the legislature's fall sitting. Groups such as the Winnipeg Humane Society have joined the battle and are calling on the NDP government to pass the bill."
For me, this is great news. I live with a cat, and I can tell you that Ontario has had a ban on "no pets" policies for many years, and it hasn't pushed landlords out of business. I lived in Ontario for several years, and I can tell you the system isn't collapsing due to a ban on no-pets policies.
I would expect the governing NDP, a nominally social democratic party, to be on the side of the property-less over the property owners in a case like this. Here's a chance for social democrats to show their superior capacity for compassion, right?
Sadly, no.
"'It is hoped that the damage deposit provision ... will encourage more landlords to welcome tenants with pets,' Rachel Morgan, press secretary to Family Services Minister Gord Mackintosh, wrote in an email."
Oh, yes. That idea. Pet damage deposits. An idea lifted from British Columbia's right-wing government, without any evidence that it has succeeded in producing more pet-friendly accommodations for renters.
Brilliant play, that.
"Gerrard is hopeful, however, that the government may change its mind, especially in the face of public pressure."
Good luck with that. The current premier is the guy who pushed the damage-deposit policy through (when he was finance minister) despite the extra burden it will mean to pet owners, and despite the utter lack of evidence that it's an effective policy in any way. He considered the landlords' viewpoints, paid no attention to any arguments against the policy, and gave the landlords a gift like any good friend of the powerful would.
It's not too late for the NDP to show that it cares, but I won't hold my breath waiting for that to happen.
Showing posts with label tenants. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tenants. Show all posts
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
About the NDP leadership race ...
I'll say this just once to get it off my chest: A cabinet minister who cares more about landlords than tenants is not suitable to lead a social democratic party -- not even one that just pretends to be a social democratic party.
My MLA, the finance minister who listened only to landlords regarding the tenants-and-pets issue here in Manitoba, has proven himself a pal to landlords and (at best) indifferent to the property-less.
The director of the Residential Tenancies Branch told me by letter in May that the pet damage deposit policy (passed into law weeks later) was "based on comments made by a local landlords' association." She also conceded that the branch has no real evidence that pet deposits have succeeded in opening up suites for pet owners in B.C.
Here's part of my reply to her letter: "In short, your letter tells me the Residential Tenancies Branch has no evidence to support a pet deposit policy and the government is following the advice of 'a local landlords' association.' I find that interesting, and I appreciate the insight.
"The admittedly anecdotal evidence I have collected so far indicates the policy has not worked in British Columbia. In the absence of solid evidence that it would work here, and given that an extra deposit would be a burden on tenants, the government ought to abandon this policy direction for now. It seems unwise to proceed with a policy that will be costly to some people and may have no benefit at all."
Of course, the government cared not one whit about the policy's impact on tenants. It gave the landlords what they wanted, like a good party of the business class.
Kudos to the Liberal party's leader for attempting to get a prohibition on "no pets" policies, by the way.
There. That felt good.
My MLA, the finance minister who listened only to landlords regarding the tenants-and-pets issue here in Manitoba, has proven himself a pal to landlords and (at best) indifferent to the property-less.
The director of the Residential Tenancies Branch told me by letter in May that the pet damage deposit policy (passed into law weeks later) was "based on comments made by a local landlords' association." She also conceded that the branch has no real evidence that pet deposits have succeeded in opening up suites for pet owners in B.C.
Here's part of my reply to her letter: "In short, your letter tells me the Residential Tenancies Branch has no evidence to support a pet deposit policy and the government is following the advice of 'a local landlords' association.' I find that interesting, and I appreciate the insight.
"The admittedly anecdotal evidence I have collected so far indicates the policy has not worked in British Columbia. In the absence of solid evidence that it would work here, and given that an extra deposit would be a burden on tenants, the government ought to abandon this policy direction for now. It seems unwise to proceed with a policy that will be costly to some people and may have no benefit at all."
Of course, the government cared not one whit about the policy's impact on tenants. It gave the landlords what they wanted, like a good party of the business class.
Kudos to the Liberal party's leader for attempting to get a prohibition on "no pets" policies, by the way.
There. That felt good.
Monday, April 20, 2009
Show me the evidence
One curious thing about the Manitoba finance minister's strategy for persuading landlords to open more suites for pet owners: Mr. Selinger has offered no evidence that the policy would work.
And it's not as if it hasn't been tried elsewhere. B.C. has had pet damage deposits in its landlord-tenant rules for a couple of years.
If the Manitoba government wants to know how well the policy works, it could see what's happened in B.c.
I've asked B.C.'s housing department for data, to no avail. As well, citizens' groups and activists with whom I've communicated don't know of any studies measuring how many more rental units are open for pet owners now compared to before pet deposits. So, sadly, I have no hard data to test whether Selinger's proposed tinkering with the market might be a good move.
But the anecdotal evidence doesn't look good.
Consider a piece last year at a B.C. website. The author relates how few dog-friendly accommodations were available when she went apartment-hunting in Vancouver.
Furthermore, the exceptions tended to be sub-par (to put it mildly): "If it's dog-friendly, it's a grimy basement suite with poor lighting and the stale smell reminiscent of that classmate's house you visited in Grade 2 -- the classmate allowed to drink as much strawberry Quick as he wanted, who had no bedtime, and a mother who smoked inside."
Then there's this January 2009 item from a Vancouver newspaper's bulletin board: "On Dec. 2, West End resident June MacGregor and six other cat-owners in the Emerald Terrace highrise were served 14-day notices to remove their pets or face eviction. On Monday, their landlord delivered eviction notices dated for Feb. 28."
It doesn't sound like being able to collect an extra deposit made that landlord any more pet-friendly.
A journalist friend in B.C. told me what everyone else has been telling me: It's extremely difficult to find a pet-friendly rental unit in B.C. (She's a homeowner, if that matters to you, if that makes her perception more valid to you.)
So, has the pet deposit policy worked in B.C.? All the evidence I've found so far says N-O.
And it's not as if it hasn't been tried elsewhere. B.C. has had pet damage deposits in its landlord-tenant rules for a couple of years.
If the Manitoba government wants to know how well the policy works, it could see what's happened in B.c.
I've asked B.C.'s housing department for data, to no avail. As well, citizens' groups and activists with whom I've communicated don't know of any studies measuring how many more rental units are open for pet owners now compared to before pet deposits. So, sadly, I have no hard data to test whether Selinger's proposed tinkering with the market might be a good move.
But the anecdotal evidence doesn't look good.
Consider a piece last year at a B.C. website. The author relates how few dog-friendly accommodations were available when she went apartment-hunting in Vancouver.
Furthermore, the exceptions tended to be sub-par (to put it mildly): "If it's dog-friendly, it's a grimy basement suite with poor lighting and the stale smell reminiscent of that classmate's house you visited in Grade 2 -- the classmate allowed to drink as much strawberry Quick as he wanted, who had no bedtime, and a mother who smoked inside."
Then there's this January 2009 item from a Vancouver newspaper's bulletin board: "On Dec. 2, West End resident June MacGregor and six other cat-owners in the Emerald Terrace highrise were served 14-day notices to remove their pets or face eviction. On Monday, their landlord delivered eviction notices dated for Feb. 28."
It doesn't sound like being able to collect an extra deposit made that landlord any more pet-friendly.
A journalist friend in B.C. told me what everyone else has been telling me: It's extremely difficult to find a pet-friendly rental unit in B.C. (She's a homeowner, if that matters to you, if that makes her perception more valid to you.)
So, has the pet deposit policy worked in B.C.? All the evidence I've found so far says N-O.
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Pet deposit hasn't worked in B.C.
I get e-mail. A citizen on the Left Coast has this to say about pet deposits:
"I would urge the Manitoba government to drop the fanciful idea that pet deposits will encourage landlords to allow pets. It simply doesn't work. We have that policy (in B.C.) and in Victoria, where I live, all the major large property management companies have a strict "no pet" policy in ever building they own, which must amount to close to 3/4 of available rentals in the city. Pet deposits are not effective in promoting pet-friendly rental accommodation."
(Emphasis added.)
See, Mr. Selinger? The policy you're pushing is a proven failure.
Please go back to the drawing board, Mr. Finance Minister.
"I would urge the Manitoba government to drop the fanciful idea that pet deposits will encourage landlords to allow pets. It simply doesn't work. We have that policy (in B.C.) and in Victoria, where I live, all the major large property management companies have a strict "no pet" policy in ever building they own, which must amount to close to 3/4 of available rentals in the city. Pet deposits are not effective in promoting pet-friendly rental accommodation."
(Emphasis added.)
See, Mr. Selinger? The policy you're pushing is a proven failure.
Please go back to the drawing board, Mr. Finance Minister.
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Please, let's not call this a 'fluffy law'
News media have paid little attention to Tuesday's announcement that the Manitoba government plans to let landlords impose an extra deposit fee on tenants with cats and dogs.
What little coverage I've seen, however, leaves me feeling depressed.
On CityTV, the Winnipeg Humane Society's executive director gave the finance minister a figurative pat on the head -- which seemed to me like a retreat from the society's position of a few months ago.
At the Winnipeg Free Press's website (but, as far as I can tell, not in the newspaper itself), there's a three-paragraph brief that calls the Residential Tenancies Act amendment "the so-called 'fluffy law.'"
Well, hold on a minute.
What the finance minister wants isn't anything like Ontario's noted "Fluffy Law."
The Ontario law, named after a senior's beloved cat, nullified "no pets" clauses in leases across that province.
Manitoba's finance minister is putting forward a bill allowing landlords to continue with "no pets" policies as they wish.
See the difference? I knew you could.
As the Winnipeg Dogs blog suggests, you might want to let the finance minister know what you think at minfin@leg.gov.mb.ca.
What little coverage I've seen, however, leaves me feeling depressed.
On CityTV, the Winnipeg Humane Society's executive director gave the finance minister a figurative pat on the head -- which seemed to me like a retreat from the society's position of a few months ago.
At the Winnipeg Free Press's website (but, as far as I can tell, not in the newspaper itself), there's a three-paragraph brief that calls the Residential Tenancies Act amendment "the so-called 'fluffy law.'"
Well, hold on a minute.
What the finance minister wants isn't anything like Ontario's noted "Fluffy Law."
The Ontario law, named after a senior's beloved cat, nullified "no pets" clauses in leases across that province.
Manitoba's finance minister is putting forward a bill allowing landlords to continue with "no pets" policies as they wish.
See the difference? I knew you could.
As the Winnipeg Dogs blog suggests, you might want to let the finance minister know what you think at minfin@leg.gov.mb.ca.
Monday, April 6, 2009
Government presents gift to landlords
"Finance Minister Greg Selinger today introduced proposed amendments to Manitoba’s Residential Tenancies Act which include provisions which would allow landlords to request a pet deposit.
"'By allowing a landlord to collect a separate pet damage deposit, we are hoping more landlords will permit pets,' said Selinger. 'The pet deposit would act as a damage deposit specific to any damage to a rental property caused by a pet.'
"Landlords in Manitoba are not required to accept pets but, if they choose to do so, they would be entitled to collect a pet damage deposit of one half month’s rent in addition to the existing security deposit."
That third paragraph in today's government news release is the key to understanding what the Manitoba government is doing. The finance minister is intent on giving landlords the right to charge an extra deposit fee on tenants with pets but imposing absolutely no requirement that landlords accept pets. It's doing this on the mere hope that more landlords will accept pets.
This is of no benefit to tenants with pets. It's a boon to landlords only.
I've posted on this topic before. I won't bother repeating here what's wrong with the government's proposal. I'm just plain sick and tired of seeing a nominally social democratic government so intent on handing a gift to the propertied class, at tenants' expense.
"'By allowing a landlord to collect a separate pet damage deposit, we are hoping more landlords will permit pets,' said Selinger. 'The pet deposit would act as a damage deposit specific to any damage to a rental property caused by a pet.'
"Landlords in Manitoba are not required to accept pets but, if they choose to do so, they would be entitled to collect a pet damage deposit of one half month’s rent in addition to the existing security deposit."
That third paragraph in today's government news release is the key to understanding what the Manitoba government is doing. The finance minister is intent on giving landlords the right to charge an extra deposit fee on tenants with pets but imposing absolutely no requirement that landlords accept pets. It's doing this on the mere hope that more landlords will accept pets.
This is of no benefit to tenants with pets. It's a boon to landlords only.
I've posted on this topic before. I won't bother repeating here what's wrong with the government's proposal. I'm just plain sick and tired of seeing a nominally social democratic government so intent on handing a gift to the propertied class, at tenants' expense.
Friday, August 22, 2008
End the heartbreak
Over at the Winnipeg Dogs blog, a commenter relates the "heartbreaking" experience of her mother having to part ways with a pet because of a landlord's policy.
That's exactly the sort of plight that could be avoided if only Manitoba would abolish "no pets" policies with a simple amendment to its Residential Tenancies Act.
Instead, the government appears to have chosen a more complicated route that involves a big dose of faith in the market.
In an e-mail to me this week, someone in Manitoba Finance (which has the Residential Tenancies Branch under its umbrella) described the government's plan as "to allow landlords to collect a pet damage deposit in the hopes that this would encourage landlords to consider pets in rental units."
It seems a big mistake for the government to think that adding such a slight incentive would work. It's as if the government learned nothing from its experience with payday loan businesses, which had to be forced via regulation to (partially) clean up their act.
The market didn't nudge the payday loan companies into better practices. Why does the Finance Minister think a little market tinkering will change arrogant property management companies?
Here's the logical, simple route the government should take: Amend the act the same way Ontario amended its Residential Tenancies Act many years ago.
Just add these words to the act: "A provision in a tenancy agreement prohibiting the presence of animals in or about the residential complex is void."
That's exactly the sort of plight that could be avoided if only Manitoba would abolish "no pets" policies with a simple amendment to its Residential Tenancies Act.
Instead, the government appears to have chosen a more complicated route that involves a big dose of faith in the market.
In an e-mail to me this week, someone in Manitoba Finance (which has the Residential Tenancies Branch under its umbrella) described the government's plan as "to allow landlords to collect a pet damage deposit in the hopes that this would encourage landlords to consider pets in rental units."
It seems a big mistake for the government to think that adding such a slight incentive would work. It's as if the government learned nothing from its experience with payday loan businesses, which had to be forced via regulation to (partially) clean up their act.
The market didn't nudge the payday loan companies into better practices. Why does the Finance Minister think a little market tinkering will change arrogant property management companies?
Here's the logical, simple route the government should take: Amend the act the same way Ontario amended its Residential Tenancies Act many years ago.
Just add these words to the act: "A provision in a tenancy agreement prohibiting the presence of animals in or about the residential complex is void."
Tuesday, August 19, 2008
Dear Mr. Gerrard:
(E-mail sent this morning to the Manitoba Liberal Leader.)
I wish to bring your attention to amendments the Doer government is considering for the Residential Tenancies Act, to allow landlords to charge a "pet deposit."
My concern is that landlords will be allowed to impose another charge (albeit a deposit) on tenants but still be allowed to impose inflexible "no pets" policies -- just as Globe General Agencies and other companies do for all of their rental properties. If that's the case, an extra cost would be imposed on pet owners while giving them no more rights than they have under the status quo.
The result could be that pet owners will have just as few choices as presently among rental units but an additional cost. Rather than an advance in tenants' rights, this would be a setback.
Ontario has had a ban on landlord "no pets" policies for several years, and I can tell you as a former Ontario resident of many years that it has been successful. Renters live happily and healthily in their suites, and landlords continue to reap profits. There is no reason why inflexible "no pets" policies can't be banned here too, contrary to whatever alarmist objections landlords may raise.
Now is the time for the Manitoba government to act out of compassion for people who have companion animals but not enough money to purchase a house, so that people will no longer be forced to lie to landlords about having a cat or dog, and so that no octogenarian should be forced to forsake the quiet and peaceful cat that has been her companion for many years.
All that is required is a simple legislative amendment, which I hope you and your party would support.
Sincerely ...
I wish to bring your attention to amendments the Doer government is considering for the Residential Tenancies Act, to allow landlords to charge a "pet deposit."
My concern is that landlords will be allowed to impose another charge (albeit a deposit) on tenants but still be allowed to impose inflexible "no pets" policies -- just as Globe General Agencies and other companies do for all of their rental properties. If that's the case, an extra cost would be imposed on pet owners while giving them no more rights than they have under the status quo.
The result could be that pet owners will have just as few choices as presently among rental units but an additional cost. Rather than an advance in tenants' rights, this would be a setback.
Ontario has had a ban on landlord "no pets" policies for several years, and I can tell you as a former Ontario resident of many years that it has been successful. Renters live happily and healthily in their suites, and landlords continue to reap profits. There is no reason why inflexible "no pets" policies can't be banned here too, contrary to whatever alarmist objections landlords may raise.
Now is the time for the Manitoba government to act out of compassion for people who have companion animals but not enough money to purchase a house, so that people will no longer be forced to lie to landlords about having a cat or dog, and so that no octogenarian should be forced to forsake the quiet and peaceful cat that has been her companion for many years.
All that is required is a simple legislative amendment, which I hope you and your party would support.
Sincerely ...
Saturday, August 2, 2008
More landlord bluster
My July 31 post appears, slightly altered, in today's Winnipeg Free Press letters section.
So does another letter from the landlord side, this one telling us if you want to have a companion animal in your life you should just buy a house. Simple as that. In other words, a great big "Fuck you" to the poor.
Still no word on why Manitoba can't have a pet-friendly tenancy law like Ontario's. Just more bluster about how it would be ruinous to show compassion.
Someone I know lives in a block where management won't even allow goldfish. Apparently, that's the policy for every building under that particular property management company.
It's sheer arrogance.
To quote Bruce Cockburn: "The tenants get the dregs and landlords get the cream."
So does another letter from the landlord side, this one telling us if you want to have a companion animal in your life you should just buy a house. Simple as that. In other words, a great big "Fuck you" to the poor.
Still no word on why Manitoba can't have a pet-friendly tenancy law like Ontario's. Just more bluster about how it would be ruinous to show compassion.
Someone I know lives in a block where management won't even allow goldfish. Apparently, that's the policy for every building under that particular property management company.
It's sheer arrogance.
To quote Bruce Cockburn: "The tenants get the dregs and landlords get the cream."
Thursday, July 31, 2008
Oh, get real
In today's Free Press letters, a landlord says changing tenancy law to allow pets would be nearly disastrous.
Get real, buddy.
"No pets" policies have been banned in Ontario for several years and the system hasn't ground to a halt. Ontarians can still live peacefully and healthily in apartment buildings, and landlords still reap profits.
The Ontario experience proves a ban on "no pets" policies is workable. Period.
Get real, buddy.
"No pets" policies have been banned in Ontario for several years and the system hasn't ground to a halt. Ontarians can still live peacefully and healthily in apartment buildings, and landlords still reap profits.
The Ontario experience proves a ban on "no pets" policies is workable. Period.
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
Dear Mr. Selinger:
(E-mail sent this morning to my MLA, who also happens to be the cabinet minister responsible for Manitoba's Residential Tenancies Branch.)
Recent stories in the Winnipeg Free Press make a strong case for a change in legislation regarding residential tenancy agreements.
It has for several years been illegal for landlords to have "no pets" policies in Ontario.
Now is the time for Manitoba to legislate against such landlord policies.
Do it out of compassion for people who have companion animals but not enough money to purchase a house, so that people will no longer be forced to lie to landlords about having a cat or dog, and so that no 75-year-old should be forced to forsake the quiet and peaceful cat that has been her companion for many years.
All that is required is a simple legislative amendment. In Ontario, it was accomplished by adding this to the province's Residential Tenancies Act: "14. A provision in a tenancy agreement prohibiting the presence of animals in or about the residential complex is void."
As my MLA and the Minister of Finance, will you commit to changing the law to help tenants with pets?
I hope the answer is yes.
Sincerely ...
Recent stories in the Winnipeg Free Press make a strong case for a change in legislation regarding residential tenancy agreements.
It has for several years been illegal for landlords to have "no pets" policies in Ontario.
Now is the time for Manitoba to legislate against such landlord policies.
Do it out of compassion for people who have companion animals but not enough money to purchase a house, so that people will no longer be forced to lie to landlords about having a cat or dog, and so that no 75-year-old should be forced to forsake the quiet and peaceful cat that has been her companion for many years.
All that is required is a simple legislative amendment. In Ontario, it was accomplished by adding this to the province's Residential Tenancies Act: "14. A provision in a tenancy agreement prohibiting the presence of animals in or about the residential complex is void."
As my MLA and the Minister of Finance, will you commit to changing the law to help tenants with pets?
I hope the answer is yes.
Sincerely ...
Tuesday, July 29, 2008
Change the law
An article in today's Winnipeg Free Press gives me hope that maybe, at some time in the not-too-distant future, Manitoba renters might see fairness.
The Winnipeg Humane Society wants to challenge the province's Residential Tenancies Act because it allows landlords to impose inflexible "no pets" policies.
Right now pets are not allowed at nearly every apartment building in Winnipeg. But many renters, of course, have cats or dogs. The law forces pet owners to be liars if they wish to keep companion animals in their lives.
And, as the Free Press story says, it "causes untold heartache" to countless Manitobans every year. Imagine how an octogenarian feels when told that she can't keep her companion cat of many years if she wishes to move into an apartment. It's a sad state of affairs, and it exists because Manitoba law gives landlords the power to be unreasonable.
Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act was changed many years ago to disallow "no pets" policies. Manitoba is overdue for a similar legislative change.
I hope the society finds a lawyer to help it challenge the Residential Tenancies Act.
The Winnipeg Humane Society wants to challenge the province's Residential Tenancies Act because it allows landlords to impose inflexible "no pets" policies.
Right now pets are not allowed at nearly every apartment building in Winnipeg. But many renters, of course, have cats or dogs. The law forces pet owners to be liars if they wish to keep companion animals in their lives.
And, as the Free Press story says, it "causes untold heartache" to countless Manitobans every year. Imagine how an octogenarian feels when told that she can't keep her companion cat of many years if she wishes to move into an apartment. It's a sad state of affairs, and it exists because Manitoba law gives landlords the power to be unreasonable.
Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act was changed many years ago to disallow "no pets" policies. Manitoba is overdue for a similar legislative change.
I hope the society finds a lawyer to help it challenge the Residential Tenancies Act.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




