Showing posts with label health. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health. Show all posts

Thursday, February 18, 2010

An update on that Belgian case

I commented in November on the case of a Belgian man who was supposedly "communicating" after several years in a coma.

Skeptics were saying Rom Houben's pronouncements via keyboard were really a case of "facilitated communication," a widely discredited process.

Someone I know shrugged and said "Maybe" when I mentioned this to her. She wasn't convinced Houben's communication was a hoax.

Well, I've just read news that the physician at the centre of it all has admitted he was mistaken. Dr. Steven Laureys has looked into it and concluded "that it wasn't Houben doing the writing after all," Der Spiegel reports.

Funny how the debunking of this "miracle" case isn't getting as much mainstream news coverage as the original story. Not nearly as sexy to report that the coma guy isn't communicating after all, I suppose. And journalists don't like to admit they were hoodwinked (again) by pseudoscience.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

You said it, Dr. Dean

Howard Dean has been watching the twists and turns in U.S. health-care reform very closely, and he's not happy with what he's been seeing.
Here's what he had to say on MSNBC last night before interviewing fellow Vermont politician Senator Bernie Sanders:
"With the Senate now less than a week away from debating health-care reform, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid now has a choice: stand firm on the public option or compromise it to get something passed.
"Those on the compromise side argue that we should just let the bill pass without a public option so we can get all of the good insurance reform that's in the bill. But there's a dirty little secret about this: The insurance reform is gone.
"In order to have insurance reform, you need two things. The first is making sure insurance companies can't turn you down for any reason. That's called guaranteed issue, and that's in the bill. But that's only effective if the coverage is affordable, and that's not in the bill.
"As the bill is written now, the insurance companies will still be allowed to gouge their customers if they have illnesses, to charge you two or three times what your neighbour gets charged.
"A lot of the insurance reform in this bill is gone. The only real reform that's left is the public option. And if that's compromised away, this bill is no longer health-care reform -- it's just a huge gift to the health insurance industry from the very same people who bailed AIG out, the American taxpayers."

U.S. health-care reform is a long, winding, confounding road. And these days I'm not sure it's leading to a very nice place.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Skeptical about that Belgian case

When I saw a TV news report yesterday about a Belgian man supposedly communicating after 23 years of uttering not a peep, my bullshit detector started to beep loudly.
For one thing, his "communication" was via computer keyboard in what looked to me like "facilitated communication" (FC).
FC was a big thing about 20 years ago, when parents of kids with brain damage, severe autism and the like thought those children were expressing themselves by typing on a keyboard or pointing to pictures and letters on a board. Which would have been awesome if it were the slightest bit true.
The countless parents who used FC with their children were, in fact, talking to themselves.
Turns out I'm not the only one to spot the probable FC hoax in this new Belgian case.
Here's what The Skeptic's Dictionary says: "Most of the stories I've seen on the topic claim the fellow is using a computer to communicate. The whole truth is that he is (literally) being manipulated by a facilitator. ... It is obvious that this poor fellow is having his finger dragged by his facilitator to letters on a board."
Skepdic also links to James Randi's commentary on the case. As a longtime fan of Randi, I'm eager to read his observations. Sadly, that link wasn't working this morning.
The unskeptical news stories that have been coming out about this case are harmful for at least two reasons: They hand a (fallacious) talking point to "right to life" kooks who never want to see life-support withdrawn from patients who have been in vegetative states for years (remember Terri Schiavo?), and they wrongly make the families of such patients feel horribly guilty for wanting to have life-support halted.
News media have done a lousy job covering the story so far. I hope they smarten up soon.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The right reasons

There are two kinds of people in the world: those who put people into categories and those who don't. By the foregoing statement you can see where I fit in.
Of those Democrats who voted against the health-care reform bill Saturday night, there are two types: those who voted nay for the wrong reasons and those few who did so for the right reasons.
Dennis Kucinich is in the latter category.
The fact the Stupak amendment compromised women's reproductive rights makes the bill seriously flawed, to put it mildly.
But Kucinich put his finger on the bill's greatest shortcoming in one paragraph of his essay at Common Dreams:
"During the debate, when the interests of insurance companies would have been effectively challenged, that challenge was turned back. The 'robust public option' which would have offered a modicum of competition to a monopolistic industry was whittled down from an initial potential enrollment of 129 million Americans to 6 million. An amendment which would have protected the rights of states to pursue single-payer health care was stripped from the bill at the request of the Administration. Looking ahead, we cringe at the prospect of even greater favors for insurance companies."

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

What's Wrong with U.S. Health Care, Chapter 457

Here's a story out of California that illustrates how heartless and immoral profit-based health care can be. From the Sacramento Bee:
"A letter of sympathy should have arrived at the home of Gerald and Elizabeth Hawkins 10 days after their son Scott was beaten to death.
"Instead, UC Davis Medical Center officials were apologizing Tuesday to the Hawkins family over a clerical error that instead sent them a $29,000 bill and a form letter suggesting their slain son was medically indigent."


Is this just an anomaly? No. I've come across countless stories like this one -- stories in which patients in the United States are treated like customers rather than people with vital needs.
How many similar stories have I encountered from Canadian centres? Not even one. That's because we Canadians don't let greed run rampant through our hospital hallways. U.S. Americans could learn something from that.
Quoting the Bee again: "Hospital officials Tuesday continued to scrutinize how the error occurred ..."
Well, it never would have occurred if the U.S. health-care system didn't stink of avarice. It would never have occurred up here in Canada, where people can go to a hospital ER without fear of getting a bill for an amount large enough for a new car purchase.
The hospital apologized and said it'll try to make sure no other family goes through what the Hawkins family experienced, but really it's inevitable that slip-ups like this one will happen as long as it's "normal" for hospitals to charge people an arm and a leg for health care.
Hospital officials can never give a satisfactory answer to the question posed by Gerald Hawkins: "Why, in any civilized society, would a hospital send the parents of a murdered boy a bill and letter like this?"

Sunday, November 1, 2009

Your shampoo may be poisoning you

Yesterday's topic reminded me of an article a friend sent me a few weeks ago about what's put in shampoos to give your hair extra shine or a silky smooth feeling. I can't find the article now, but a British website does a nice job of giving you the lowdown on what might be in that bottle.
"Diethanolamine (DEA) is a chemical found in shampoos which helps to create the soapy lather. ... But if DEA reacts with other ingredients ... it's possible that a substance called nitrosodiethanolamine (NDELA) is formed which is a known carcinogen.
"Some dyes used in shampoos ... are suspected carcinogens and best avoided.
"Propyelene glycol is a petrochemical which acts a synthetic binder and softener ... However, yet again it is a suspected carcinogen and can also cause contact dermatitis."

Etc.
Read the summary and it'll change the way you look at that shampoo in your bathroom.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Fun with a candy wrapper

"You can spend a really depressing hour googling the ingredients from the wrapper of the candy you just ate," states a two-year-old business magazine article I read recently.
I reckoned the research exercise would be more fun than depressing for me.
With a box of Mike and Ike Berry Blast in front of me, I began my investigation.
Sugar is first on the list, of course. This ubiquitous ingredient is bad for you because it's a mountain of calories without any vitamins, and because it raises insulin levels, which depresses the immune system, causes weight gain, increases your risk of diabetes and has many more unwanted consequences.
Next up is corn syrup, basically just another sugar.
Malic acid, found naturally in apples and other fruit, adds a tartness to the candy. It can actually boost your immune system.
Sodium citrate is another flavouring ingredient, though sometimes it's used as part of treatment for kidney stones.
Confectioner's glaze, also called (depending on use) pharmaceutical glaze, is the most interesting ingredient of the bunch. It's commonly made from an insect secretion.
Magnesium hydroxide, a filler, is sometimes used as a flame retardant in plastics and synthetic rubber. It's also a common antacid and laxative (milk of magnesia).
Overall, I gotta say the information I found doesn't bother me much. I still enjoy my Mike and Ikes -- insect secretions, flame retardant, empty calories and all.
Enjoy those Halloween candies, kids.

Friday, September 4, 2009

The truth, from real Canadians

Here's a 10-minute video every U.S. citizen should see. Especially the ones who either don't understand Canada's health-care model or have been defaming it.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

What is B.C. doing?

Excellent column by Dan Lett today in Winnipeg's broadsheet, about the "lunacy" of cutting health and education to battle a deficit.
British Columbia's conservative Liberal government hasn't learned from history, Lett writes. "We saw what happened when we cut doctors, nurses, hospital beds and surgeries. We had longer and longer waits for procedures, overworked doctors and nurses, and ultimately bigger bills to correct all these problems."
Now, after worsening the province's fiscal problems last autumn with senseless tax cuts, the B.C. government has announced that it simply must slash funding to schools and hospitals to keep the budget deficit down.
So it goes.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Ebert supports universal health care

"I believe universal health care is, quite simply, right."
That's how Roger Ebert, Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic, sums up his support for meaningful health-care reform in the United States.
"It is a moral imperative," he continues on his blog. "I cannot enjoy health coverage and turn to my neighbor and tell him he doesn't deserve it."
Exactly. That is why I find opposition to universal health care not just puzzling but a sign of moral deficiency.
Rep. Roy Blunt and his Canada-bashing ilk might want to take note of this observation: "Although we're assured by opponents of the Obama legislation that Canada's system of universal care is a failure, all of [Ebert's Canadian readers who wrote in on this topic], without exception, reported their enthusiasm for their nation's system."
To a reader who opposes health-care reform for philosophical reasons, Ebert had this reply: "I hope your philosophy will be of comfort if you develop a serious illness."
Ebert himself has battled cancer in recent years. His case illustrates how even a Yankee with a six-figure -- maybe seven-figure -- income and (in his case) two health insurance plans is financially vulnerable to a catastrophic illness.
In fact, he writes, "during the course of four major surgeries -- no, make that five -- I maxed out one [insurance policy], and so much for that policy. I'm approaching the cap on the second. Most policies aren't unlimited, you know. Luckily, I now qualify for Medicare."
Now imagine what would have happened to Ebert if he didn't have two insurance policies, and wasn't a high-income earner. Where would he be now if he were just a working-class guy with a working-class job?
Something to think about.

Friday, August 21, 2009

U.S. pol looks north and maligns Canadian system

Canada's "socialized" health care continues to get a lot of attention in the United States as the latter wrestles with how to fix a deeply flawed system.
The continued attention is somewhat puzzling, since the U.S. president has made it clear that his administration doesn't want to copy Canadian medicare.
Obama said earlier this month that the Canuck model "would not work for the United States, in part simply because we've evolved differently. We have an employer-based system and a private-based health care system that stands side-by-side with Medicare and Medicaid and our Veterans Administration health care system. And so, we've got to develop a uniquely American approach to this problem."
Which, by the way, is similar to what I wrote Aug. 11.
Yet, despite the president saying that's not the way he wants to go, opponents of U.S. health-care reform keep on trying to scare people with horror stories to illustrate what a terrible system Canada has. A terrible system with proportionally fewer dying newborns and higher average life expectancy, mind you, but it's socialist, dammit, and that ain't good.
Consider the wildly ill-informed words of Roy Blunt, a Republican congressman from Missouri who heads up his party's Health Care Solutions Group.
He recently told a St. Louis newspaper that at his ripe old age of 59, the government health czars up here would treat him as a second-class citizen. "In either Canada or Great Britain, if I broke my hip, I couldn't get it replaced."
The newspaper did a little research and found that 63 per cent of hip replacement patients in Canada are 65 or older.
Blunt thanked the paper for the correction and said "I won't use that example any more."
I wonder what silly "fact" he'll be using in its place.
Why am I not surprised that Blunt, who wants a seat in the upper house, also refuses to acknowledge that the "birthers" are out of their freakin' minds?
That's a rhetorical question, of course.
I'm also not surprised that the insurance industry loves him.

Friday, August 14, 2009

It's good for you, mostly, maybe

Another thing about coffee: It's good for you.
It lowers your risk of diabetes and colon cancer, according to some medical researchers.
Then again, caffeine raises blood pressure.
What to do, what to do ...
Oh, I know.
I'll have another cup.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Way down south

The Globe and Mail reports that Canada's "socialized" health-care system has become a hot topic in yet another country: South Africa.
The governing African National Congress party wants to do something about the horrible inequities in South Africa's system, and it's looking at Canada's system as a model.
Writes Geoffrey York: "The debates in the United States and South Africa are oddly similar. Both countries feature a vastly unequal two-tier system, where the elites enjoy the luxuries of unlimited care, while millions are too poor to afford medical treatment."
As in the U.S., the discourse in Africa's southernmost country includes interventions from lobby groups for the status quo who say Canada's system is a mess. Presumably, just as in the U.S., these people aren't proposing a way to ensure access for all like a civilized society.
My first thought when I saw the Globe story was "Why would Canada's system get this much attention in a country so far away?"
It's not as if Canadian medicare is the only universal health care system in the world. There are plenty of other systems that South Africa could use as models.
In fact, South Africa could look to any industrialized country other than the U.S. for models of how to ensure decent health care for rich and poor alike.
Colour me puzzled.
(Thanks to New Canadian Bob for alerting me to the Globe story.)

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Merits of the public option

Obama et al. have taken some criticism from the left for pursuing "weak" health-care reform.
Some say the "public option" isn't good enough when other countries have single-payer systems that work well.
While I sympathize with their cause, I say these people ought to ease off on the criticism. Public option may well be the best course for the U.S. right now.
Here's why.
A single-payer system would be extremely difficult to implement in a country of 300 million that has never had anything like it.
The big players who are resisting the public option now would fight against going single-payer even harder. They would play the anti-government passions of half the U.S. population like Yo-Yo Ma playing a cello.
Even if the battle were won, it might well be a pyrrhic victory followed by one of the biggest, most daunting government undertakings in U.S. history.
But it seems that a good public option, not watered down to please the Blue Dogs or whatever "reasonable" Republicans there are, could achieve the basic objectives of health-care reform: health insurance for all, and cost reduction.
It would give the uninsured an option, and as a major player with tens of millions of policy holders the government would force the private sector to find efficiencies. In the end, health care would be available to more people and eat up less of the GDP.
In short, a good public option could make the health-care system more civilized and more efficient. Those would be big victories for the public good.
One way in which you could say I'm conservative is that I generally prefer to see change come at a slow pace. Or at least I'm averse to really fast change. Too much change at once can mean instability, because a system can adjust to only so much at a time.
So I say cut Obama some slack on this issue. Fight for the change that's possible now. Maybe you could think of this as the first stage in transforming the system.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Lessons to be learned

What with certain Canadians gleefully enabling the liars and the ignorant in the health-care debate going on in the United States, it's nice to see one of Canada's most distinguished experts on health care saying his piece in a major U.S. paper.
As Michael Rachlis points out, "there are lessons to be learned" by simply observing the experiences of other countries. But sadly, there's woefully too little of that learning going on in the U.S. regarding health-care systems.
The best part of Rachlis's L.A. Times piece is in the penultimate paragraph, where he notes the "traditional American ignorance of what happens north of the border, which makes it easy to mislead people. Boilerplate anti-government rhetoric does the same. The U.S. media, legislators and even presidents have claimed that our 'socialized' system doesn't let us choose our own doctors. In fact, Canadians have free choice of physicians. It's Americans these days who are restricted to 'in-plan' doctors.
"Unfortunately, many Americans won't get to hear the straight goods because vested interests are promoting a caricature of the Canadian experience."

(A tip o' the hat to Emily at Sozadee for making me aware of Rachlis's essay.)

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Some Canucks tell damnable lies about their country. Shame on them

Canadians live longer than U.S. residents, and fewer of their children die in infancy. If you live in Canada, you are substantially more likely to see your 60th birthday.
Despite these positive outcomes, and despite the fact they're achieved on much less money, the Canadian health-care system has been maligned south of the border as some legislators oppose any plan to see that all Americans can get health insurance.
Of special interest to me -- and by that I mean it pisses me off -- is the help certain Canadians have lent to those in the U.S. who would use a market-worshipping philosophy to condemn fellow citizens to death for lack of health care.
Take a bow, Shona Holmes, you lying sack of shit. Or, rather, duck those rotten tomatoes coming your way. Brain tumour? Nope, a cyst. Six months from death? Not true. Ms. Holmes's testimony in a TV commercial against universal health care was a disgraceful package of mendacity.
A special walk of shame for Dr. Gratzer, a Canadian physician who pretends to understand my country's system. All he understands is that it's not anything like the market-based system he wants to see. A Democrat gave him a good smackdown, exposing Gratzer's ignorance, at a recent hearing in Washington:

Bravo, Mr. Kucinich.
Fuck you, Dr. Gratzer.
By the way ... it's nice to see Canadian opposition politicians combatting the lies in the U.S., and sad to see Canada's health minister doing nothing to set the record straight. Could her silence have anything to do with Prime Minister Harper's connection to an organization that hates medicare?

Saturday, June 20, 2009

How doctors and insurers are like a passive-aggressive spouse

Many years ago, long before my hair started greying, I hung out with a charismatic social worker who was once a champion runner.
K, as I'll call him here and now, had a distinct charm, a way with the ladies that I could only dream of having. He was neither rich nor handsome, and his once-athletic frame had been painted over by a middle-age paunch. But he was whip smart and sensitive to women's concerns. Apparently, that goes a long way with some members of the distaff set.
One day, at his apartment, I overheard a message on his answering machine. It was from a married woman he knew and went something like this: "K, I'm sorry but I can't go to the party tonight, X [her husband] got wind of it and came up with a million reasons why I shouldn't go."
X, of course, wasn't concerned about his wife's well-being. He was just worried K might steal his wife. X was thinking only of himself and his own interests.
I thought of this event the other day while watching a TV news story about opposition to the "public option" in U.S. health care proposed by the Obama administration.
The American Medical Association and the insurance sector are opposed because, well, they like the status quo. It's been quite profitable for them.
They're like that spouse in my story. They will devise and put forth a million reasons why the people and government should not pursue the public option.
And their motives are entirely selfish. They don't care about the people's well-being. They care only about themselves.
Don't listen to them, America. Don't listen to them.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Obama on health

In last week's McCain-Obama debate, Obama referred to his mother's tragic story to make a compelling case for health care as a right, not a privilege.
Obama's health-care plan for the United States isn't nearly as good as the system Canadians already enjoy and have been enjoying for decades, but it would certainly be an improvement compared to what Yankees have now.
I wonder how many Canadians are aware of Prime Minister Harper's background as head of the National Citizens' Coalition, which was founded to oppose medicare and remains opposed to it.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

McCain's health care

When you've spent all your life enjoying the benefits of taxpayer-funded health care, you really shouldn't deride taxpayer-funded health care. That's a lesson John McCain should have learned by now.
But he hasn't.
This week, a journalist in Iowa posed a legitimate question to the U.S. presidential candidate: "Throughout your adult life, am I right, as a veteran and a member of Congress and now someone over 65, have you always been covered ... by a taxpayer-financed health care plan?"
His response was a seemingly reluctant acknowledgment that, yes, he has benefited from state-funded health care but he's opposed to it generally because has too much faith in the free market and each family's ability to make the best choices. Oh, and there's that whole "government bureaucracy" problem.
Health care is one policy area in which the United States is some 40-plus years behind Canada. In the early 1960s, Saskatchewanians heard the same arguments against "socialized" medicine that U.S. citizens are still giving respectful attention. The issue has been settled, Canadians have a single-payer system, and only market ideologues and extreme libertarians would have it any other way.