Wednesday, November 4, 2009

What's Wrong with U.S. Health Care, Chapter 457

Here's a story out of California that illustrates how heartless and immoral profit-based health care can be. From the Sacramento Bee:
"A letter of sympathy should have arrived at the home of Gerald and Elizabeth Hawkins 10 days after their son Scott was beaten to death.
"Instead, UC Davis Medical Center officials were apologizing Tuesday to the Hawkins family over a clerical error that instead sent them a $29,000 bill and a form letter suggesting their slain son was medically indigent."


Is this just an anomaly? No. I've come across countless stories like this one -- stories in which patients in the United States are treated like customers rather than people with vital needs.
How many similar stories have I encountered from Canadian centres? Not even one. That's because we Canadians don't let greed run rampant through our hospital hallways. U.S. Americans could learn something from that.
Quoting the Bee again: "Hospital officials Tuesday continued to scrutinize how the error occurred ..."
Well, it never would have occurred if the U.S. health-care system didn't stink of avarice. It would never have occurred up here in Canada, where people can go to a hospital ER without fear of getting a bill for an amount large enough for a new car purchase.
The hospital apologized and said it'll try to make sure no other family goes through what the Hawkins family experienced, but really it's inevitable that slip-ups like this one will happen as long as it's "normal" for hospitals to charge people an arm and a leg for health care.
Hospital officials can never give a satisfactory answer to the question posed by Gerald Hawkins: "Why, in any civilized society, would a hospital send the parents of a murdered boy a bill and letter like this?"

13 comments:

Jack Jodell said...

Utterly heartless and disgusting. Stuff like this makes my Irish blood boil. HUMAN NEEDS BEFORE PROFIT!!!! Stimpson, I admire you Canadians for your sense of decency and your intelligent approach to taking care of your fellow citizens. You are far more advanced and civilized than we here in the U.S.!

Mike said...

Thanks, JJ. Canadian health care has its faults, but I'll take it over the U.S. model any day.

Middle Ditch said...

British healthcare has it's faults too but this is just ridiculous.

JoBama "Truth 101" Kelly said...

I have family in Rochester and Buffalo NY. Every time I see one of them I ask how many Canadians did they see at the hospital or clinic. 47 years I've been in this family and still, not one ever saw or had to wait for a Canadian at the clinic.

To listen to the liars on the right, you'd think Canadians would be swimming in droves across the Niagara River to get some of our great health care at a great value.

TomCat said...

The best think that could happen to US health care is to transplant the Canadian system here.

Mike said...

yes, Truth, as you say, the U.S. right has lied outrageously about Canadians and their health-care system. I don't personally know any Canadians who have gone to the U.S. for health care, except for an Alberta woman I interviewed 10 years ago who went to Texas for controversial cancer treatment.

I agree a single-payer system is (in theory, at least) the best, TomCat, but it's not a realistic goal for the U.S. right now. Easier to implement a public option.

Nice of you to drop in, Middle Ditch. I intend to listen to some of your radio plays soon.

Kentucky Rain said...

Somehow I missed this! Chilling..just chilling!

primerica insurance said...

Yet another proof of how the current system is just rotten. A system in which profit is more important than patient's health is the worst one possible. It's just sad that the people who are opposing this new system (Fox News watchers mainly I'd guess) are not intelligent enough to see this and listen to the countless stories of people who have been denied health care simply to save money and make more profit...just sad.

Take care, Lorne

libhom said...

"patients in the United States are treated like customers rather than people with vital needs"

This phrase makes two really important points. Aside from the intended one, it points out how treating customers badly is taken for granted in this society.

Anonymous said...

welchen Charakter der Arbeit sehend cialis ohne rezept levitra bestellen [url=http//t7-isis.org]cialis 20mg preisvergleich[/url]

Anonymous said...

si Hay unos anГЎlogos? [url=http://csalamanca.com/category/viagra/ ]viagra es malo [/url] Por favor, expliquen mГЎs detalladamente http://csalamanca.com/tag/sin-receta/ viagra sin receta en andorra

Anonymous said...

Incredibile argomento [url=http://lacasadicavour.com/ ]vendita cialis [/url]Condivido pienamente il suo punto di vista. Penso che questo sia una buona idea. http://lacasadicavour.com/cialis/ cialis 20 mg effetti Meravigliosa idea e il periodo di tempo

Anonymous said...

Gracias, se ha ido leer. [url=http://csalamanca.com/tag/comprar-viagra/ ]viagra sin receta medica [/url] Exactamente! La idea bueno, es conforme con Ud. http://csalamanca.com/tag/sin-receta/ comprar viagra sin receta