Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Earth Day music: Michelle Shocked goes green

Texas native Michelle Shocked broke into Billboard's Hot 100 in 1988 with Anchorage, a sweet song about correspondence between old friends, from her sophomore album Short Sharp Shocked. On the Greener Side, from follow-up album Captain Swing, made the top 20 of Billboard's Modern Rock chart in 1989.

Monday, April 20, 2009

Show me the evidence

One curious thing about the Manitoba finance minister's strategy for persuading landlords to open more suites for pet owners: Mr. Selinger has offered no evidence that the policy would work.
And it's not as if it hasn't been tried elsewhere. B.C. has had pet damage deposits in its landlord-tenant rules for a couple of years.
If the Manitoba government wants to know how well the policy works, it could see what's happened in B.c.
I've asked B.C.'s housing department for data, to no avail. As well, citizens' groups and activists with whom I've communicated don't know of any studies measuring how many more rental units are open for pet owners now compared to before pet deposits. So, sadly, I have no hard data to test whether Selinger's proposed tinkering with the market might be a good move.
But the anecdotal evidence doesn't look good.
Consider a piece last year at a B.C. website. The author relates how few dog-friendly accommodations were available when she went apartment-hunting in Vancouver.
Furthermore, the exceptions tended to be sub-par (to put it mildly): "If it's dog-friendly, it's a grimy basement suite with poor lighting and the stale smell reminiscent of that classmate's house you visited in Grade 2 -- the classmate allowed to drink as much strawberry Quick as he wanted, who had no bedtime, and a mother who smoked inside."
Then there's this January 2009 item from a Vancouver newspaper's bulletin board: "On Dec. 2, West End resident June MacGregor and six other cat-owners in the Emerald Terrace highrise were served 14-day notices to remove their pets or face eviction. On Monday, their landlord delivered eviction notices dated for Feb. 28."
It doesn't sound like being able to collect an extra deposit made that landlord any more pet-friendly.
A journalist friend in B.C. told me what everyone else has been telling me: It's extremely difficult to find a pet-friendly rental unit in B.C. (She's a homeowner, if that matters to you, if that makes her perception more valid to you.)
So, has the pet deposit policy worked in B.C.? All the evidence I've found so far says N-O.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Why are politicians such science ignoramuses?

Listening to the U.S. Congress's leading Republican on ABC's This Week today, I was both amused and annoyed. But mostly annoyed.
There was John Boehner dismissing the very idea of anthropogenic climate change: "The idea that carbon dioxide is a carcinogen that is harmful to our environment is almost comical. Every time we exhale, we exhale carbon dioxide. Every cow in the world, you know when they do what they do you've got more carbon dioxide."
*sigh*
Another blogger explained what's wrong with that statement very succinctly, so I'll just quote him: "(1) No one has ever claimed that carbon dioxide is a carcinogen (2) there are thousands of substances that are perfectly safe at one level of exposure and dangerous at another (say, water), and (3) cow flatulence consists of methane (CH4), not carbon dioxide (CO2)."
What bothers me most about Boehner's idiotic statement is that, among politicians, he has plenty of company in his smug ignorance. It's all too common to hear and read politicians' incredibly stupid denials of human-made global warming. Canada's current PM seems only a fairly recent "convert" to the scientific consensus on the topic.
Then there are those in government caucus in Ottawa who think evolution is "just a theory."
Canada's science minister, Gary Goodyear, tried last month to dodge a question about whether he believed in evolution by saying it's wrong to ask him about his religious beliefs. Then, just to show how much he knows about science (not much), he told an interviewer he believes we're evolving every year.
As Goodyear's foolishness faded from people's memories, a government backbencher made a statement in the House of Commons to remind people of the stupid that infects Team Harper.
James Lunney rose before question period to denounce "an attempt to ridicule the presumed beliefs of a member of this House."
Fair enough so far, I guess. We wouldn't want to hurt Goodyear's feelings, would we? Never mind that the issue was not his religious creed but rather his grasp of science and reality.
But then things got really weird. Lunney went on to dismiss evolution: "Any scientist who declares that the theory of evolution is a fact has already abandoned the foundations of science. For science establishes fact through the study of things observable and reproducible. Since origins can neither be reproduced nor observed, they remain the realm of hypothesis."
Here Lunney's breathtaking ignorance was in full bloom. He clearly doesn't understand evolution as both a fact and a theory. That is to say, scientists have observed an overwhelming volume of evidence to accept evolution as a fact, and they have developed a theory to explain it.
See how that works, Jimmy? No?
Well, maybe this analogy will help you along. Instead of evolution, think about gravity. We all acknowledge gravity exists, right? It's what keeps our feet on the ground and allows us to pee into urinals instead of up into the air.
So gravity is a fact. It's an observable fact that can be demonstrated in reproducible experiments.
But there's also a scientific theory to explain it. See? It's an acknowledged fact, with a theory to explain it.
Same with evolution. Scientists have observed so much evidence of evolution that they accept it as fact. And there's a theory to explain it.
Some have countered that Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection is on shaky ground since scientists have, over the years, found flaws and modified it.
Well, the same can be said of Newton's theory explaining gravity. That's how science works. Theories are challenged and, if found wanting, either replaced or modified. Our knowledge of the natural world grows that way.
All of the above is mostly me blowing off steam. But I'm still feeling annoyed and frustrated, because I'm not any closer to understanding why so many (mostly conservative) politicians are so woefully ignorant about science.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

On my night table: Just One Vote

Manitobans who were of voting age in 1988 should remember that the provincial government led by Howard Pawley fell in a vote of non-confidence that year as winter was winding down. A general election in April returned just 12 New Democrats to the legislature of 57, down 18 from the slim majority the NDP won in 1986.
The government fell because one embittered member of the legislative assembly, Jim Walding, voted against his party.
Acadia University poli sci professor Ian Stewart traces the events that led to the government's collapse in Just One Vote.
Stewart does an excellent job reconstructing the nomination battle of 1985-86 that Walding won by a single vote (203-202). He also tells of the tension that followed as party activists in the riding of St. Vital worked to get Walding re-elected, saw the petty jerk try unsuccessfully to blackmail Pawley into giving him a cabinet position, and then witnessed their MLA continuously criticizing and undermining the government's efforts until that day of ultimate betrayal.
But for me the best part of this book is its second and third chapters, in which Stewart gives a roughly 50-page history lesson about St. Vital, the place I called home for the first quarter-century of my life. I was surprised by how much I didn't know about the community.
Full disclosure: I was interviewed for this book, and I'm mentioned seven times as a supporter of someone who challenged Walding for the nomination in 1986.

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Pet deposit hasn't worked in B.C.

I get e-mail. A citizen on the Left Coast has this to say about pet deposits:
"I would urge the Manitoba government to drop the fanciful idea that pet deposits will encourage landlords to allow pets. It simply doesn't work. We have that policy (in B.C.) and in Victoria, where I live, all the major large property management companies have a strict "no pet" policy in ever building they own, which must amount to close to 3/4 of available rentals in the city. Pet deposits are not effective in promoting pet-friendly rental accommodation."
(Emphasis added.)
See, Mr. Selinger? The policy you're pushing is a proven failure.
Please go back to the drawing board, Mr. Finance Minister.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Please, let's not call this a 'fluffy law'

News media have paid little attention to Tuesday's announcement that the Manitoba government plans to let landlords impose an extra deposit fee on tenants with cats and dogs.
What little coverage I've seen, however, leaves me feeling depressed.
On CityTV, the Winnipeg Humane Society's executive director gave the finance minister a figurative pat on the head -- which seemed to me like a retreat from the society's position of a few months ago.
At the Winnipeg Free Press's website (but, as far as I can tell, not in the newspaper itself), there's a three-paragraph brief that calls the Residential Tenancies Act amendment "the so-called 'fluffy law.'"
Well, hold on a minute.
What the finance minister wants isn't anything like Ontario's noted "Fluffy Law."
The Ontario law, named after a senior's beloved cat, nullified "no pets" clauses in leases across that province.
Manitoba's finance minister is putting forward a bill allowing landlords to continue with "no pets" policies as they wish.
See the difference? I knew you could.
As the Winnipeg Dogs blog suggests, you might want to let the finance minister know what you think at minfin@leg.gov.mb.ca.

Monday, April 6, 2009

Government presents gift to landlords

"Finance Minister Greg Selinger today introduced proposed amendments to Manitoba’s Residential Tenancies Act which include provisions which would allow landlords to request a pet deposit.
"'By allowing a landlord to collect a separate pet damage deposit, we are hoping more landlords will permit pets,' said Selinger. 'The pet deposit would act as a damage deposit specific to any damage to a rental property caused by a pet.'
"Landlords in Manitoba are not required to accept pets but, if they choose to do so, they would be entitled to collect a pet damage deposit of one half month’s rent in addition to the existing security deposit."

That third paragraph in today's government news release is the key to understanding what the Manitoba government is doing. The finance minister is intent on giving landlords the right to charge an extra deposit fee on tenants with pets but imposing absolutely no requirement that landlords accept pets. It's doing this on the mere hope that more landlords will accept pets.
This is of no benefit to tenants with pets. It's a boon to landlords only.
I've posted on this topic before. I won't bother repeating here what's wrong with the government's proposal. I'm just plain sick and tired of seeing a nominally social democratic government so intent on handing a gift to the propertied class, at tenants' expense.

Sunday, April 5, 2009

Doing more than required

Can a government ever do too much to reduce pollution? David Schindler thinks so.
I spoke to the University of Alberta ecology professor a few months ago for a sidebar to a magazine story on water. He told me phosphorus reduction is the key to tackling the problem of eutrophication in Lake Winnipeg.
Eutrophication is the process of a lake becoming so rich in nutrients that it has an overgrowth of algae. In Manitoba's largest lake, algae growth is choking the life out of fish.
Some of Schindler's colleagues disagree with his cut-the-phosphorus prescription and say nitrogen pollutants have to be trimmed too. Manitoba's Clean Environment Commission has decided to err on the side of caution and order the City of Winnipeg cut both in the sewage treatment process.
Schindler comes out swinging today in Winnipeg's daily broadsheet to say the commission is making a mistake as "there is not a single documented case anywhere where reducing inputs of nitrogen has decreased eutrophication of a lake."
The commission is ignoring volumes of "good science," he writes. "Only removing phosphorus at point sources, such as sewage treatment plants, and reducing non-point sources (feedlots and fertilized fields) will improve Lake Winnipeg water quality ..."
What's more, says Schindler, it's an expensive mistake. "I have never hesitated to advocate spending taxpayers' money when it would restore the health of a major ecosystem, but I also feel strongly that taxpayers should be spared when expenditures will achieve no environmental gain. For $48 million [the cost of nitrogen reduction], there are many worthy environmental problems that could be addressed in Manitoba. Removal of nitrogen from Winnipeg's sewage is not one of them."
So, this is a debate not over the scientific "controversy" of whether phosphorus reduction alone will stop eutrophication. This is also about when (or whether) governments go too far in some measures they say are for the good of our ecosystem.
Is the commission forcing Winnipeg to do too much, at too high a cost to taxpayers? I'm not sure, but Schindler makes a good case that it is.

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Let freedom ring

Remember how the Bush administration liked to call its most notorious military action Operation Iraqi Freedom? Well, here's freedom for ya: 100 Iraqis face imminent execution for being gay.
Meanwhile, in Afghanistan, it's now perfectly OK for a man to rape his wife or marry a child.